§Synopsis
01Published in 2004, it is an alternative history set in 19th-century England around the time of the Napoleonic Wars. Its premise is that magic once existed in England and has returned with two men: Gilbert Norrell and Jonathan Strange. Centred on the relationship between these two men, the novel investigates the nature of "Englishness" and the boundaries between reason and unreason, Anglo-Saxon and Anglo-Dane, and Northern and Southern English cultural tropes/stereotypes. It has been described as a fantasy novel, an alternative history, and a historical novel. It inverts the Industrial Revolution conception of the North-South divide in England: in this book the North is romantic and magical, rather than rational and concrete.
§Our take
Marketing sold this as Harry Potter for adults, and that pitch has sent plenty of readers away unhappy. Kirkus said the book far outclasses the comparison, and it's right. Clarke's narrator is dry, arch and period-perfect, closer to Austen and Dickens than to any wizard school.
The real hook is the footnotes. There are about 185 of them, and together they invent a scholarly history of English magic so convincing it feels like a real one. Some readers adore them. Others find them tedious filler that stalls the plot. The book also changes as it goes: a Regency comedy of manners gradually darkens into something wintry and sinister. If the slow start charms you, the shift will hook you. If it doesn't, you'll feel every page of a very long book.
§Themes
- Reason versus madness
- The faery world is tied to perceived insanity, so the book keeps asking where sense ends and unreason begins.
- What Englishness means
- The North is romantic and magical rather than rational and concrete, which flips the usual North-South picture.
- Voices left out
- The history of magic overlooks women, people of color and the poor, and the book notices.
- Comedy that curdles
- Regency wit gives way to a sinister, Byronic mood as the faery threat grows.
- Rivals and allies
- Two very different magicians need each other, then fall out.
§How it was received
Kirkus gave it a star and treated the debut as a major work, with only a note that the climax arrives fast after so many pages. It won the 2005 Hugo Award for Best Novel. Not everyone fell for it: Michel Faber in the Guardian found it loquacious with a creaking plot, and John Clute thought the first 300 pages needed trimming.
§Read it if
- You love Austen's dry wit and want it with magic and a long, slow dread
- You like invented scholarship, footnotes included, as worldbuilding
- You want magic that feels uncanny and restrained rather than flashy
§Skip it if
- You want the pace and accessibility of Harry Potter. Readers who come for that often drop it.
- Footnotes that interrupt the story, or characters who keep you at arm's length, will wear you out.
§Before you start
- Reading experience
- Settle in: the period prose takes its time, the opening is leisurely, and the book pays back readers willing to let its dread gather.
- Reading order
- It stands alone. Piranesi is Clarke's later, much shorter novel, not a continuation.
- Content notes
- Growing sinister, melancholy tone with madness and faery menace; Set during the Napoleonic Wars.
§Common questions
- Is Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell like Harry Potter?
- Not really. The comparison was a marketing line, and Kirkus calls it misleading. This is slower, more literary and much closer to Austen than to a wizard school.
- Do I have to read the footnotes?
- They're a big part of the book's charm, but they divide readers. The long audiobook, narrated by Simon Prebble, reads them separately so listeners can skip them.
- Is there a sequel?
- No. It's a standalone novel. Clarke's later book, Piranesi, is a separate story.
§If you liked this
- Gormenghast by Mervyn Peake — A forum reader pairs it with Peake for the same eerie, elaborate atmosphere.
- Harry Potter series by J. K. Rowling — The marketing comparison, and a misleading one. This is slower and more literary.
- Piranesi by Susanna Clarke — Clarke's later, much shorter novel, for readers who want her sensibility with far less length.
- Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen — Austen's dry wit is the model for the narrator's voice.
Track this book
Add to your library to track progress and write reviews
