§Synopsis
01Working as a nanny for the world’s grumpiest single dad should have been simple. Except I can’t keep my eyes off him. And he can’t keep his hands off of me.
Cade Eaton is thirteen years older than I am and barely looks my way. Until I get him into the hot tub one night for a game of truth or dare. Then all bets are off—and so are our clothes.
He’s gruff, a little rough around the edges. But broad-shouldered ranchers with calloused hands and filthy mouths are this city girl’s kryptonite. So who am I to resist?
But it’s in our quiet moments together that he softens. It’s when he takes care of me that I realize his hardened exterior is just a façade. It’s when I watch him go all sweet with his little boy that I really fall for him.
Someone convinced him once that his best wasn’t good enough. But I’ve never felt more cherished than I do in his arms.
My contract may say this arrangement is only for two months.
But my heart says this is forever.
§Our take
Heartless is a tragedy you can see coming, and whether that works for you decides everything. Meyer knew readers would know the ending, so she let the book darken on purpose, to show how a hopeful girl gets turned. Some readers find that moving and painful. Others find it predictable.
The nicest trick is how she builds the plot from Carroll's odd details: the Queen's temper, the famous tarts, the feud with white roses. It's a puzzle-box for Alice fans. Cath's ambition is small and specific, a shop of her own, which makes her easy to root for. Some readers find her too gentle to become a tyrant. Expect something more reflective and romantic than The Lunar Chronicles, not a thrill ride.
§Themes
- A tragedy with the ending showing
- Everyone knows where Cath ends up, so the book is about how, not what.
- Baking as ambition
- Cath wants to run her own bakery, a wish to steer her own fate rather than wear a crown.
- Constraint on women's choices
- Victorian-flavoured limits on what a young woman of rank may choose press her toward her fate.
- Revenge as corrosion
- Common Sense Media reads it as a cautionary tale about how revenge eats at a person.
- Wonderland, reverse-engineered
- Carroll's quirks become mysteries the story explains, with wordplay to match.
§How it was received
Publishers Weekly admired the worldbuilding and the slow-building secret romance, but noted the stakes are lower than in Meyer's Lunar Chronicles. Common Sense Media called it an engaging origin story with less emotional weight than her other books. A public-library reviewer who usually dislikes romance loved it.
§Read it if
- You love Alice in Wonderland and enjoy spotting where a story's clues came from
- You like villain origin stories in the vein of Wicked
- You want a complete standalone with a deliberately sad ending
§Skip it if
- You want the danger and high stakes of The Lunar Chronicles
- A slow, setup-heavy opening and standard YA romance beats will lose you before the second half
§Before you start
- Reading experience
- The opening is slow and setup-heavy, and most readers say the second half is much more absorbing.
- Reading order
- Standalone. It's a prequel-style origin story to Carroll's Alice books and Meyer's first standalone YA, not part of The Lunar Chronicles.
- Content notes
- Some violence: a character willingly gives up her heart, and two beheadings occur; Romance limited to kissing; no strong language; Wine and cordials at parties; hookah smoking; Emotional ending and dark themes of betrayal and revenge may affect younger or sensitive readers.
§Common questions
- Is Heartless a standalone?
- Yes. It's a complete story with no sequel, and it isn't part of The Lunar Chronicles.
- Do I need to know Alice in Wonderland first?
- Not strictly, and some readers enjoy it on its own. One lost the thread without Carroll, though, and familiarity deepens the many allusions.
- Is Heartless appropriate for teens?
- Common Sense Media and Publishers Weekly both say 12+. Expect kissing, two beheadings and a sad ending with dark themes of betrayal and revenge.
§If you liked this
- Wicked by Gregory Maguire — Meyer named it as the spark for turning a famous villain into a sympathetic lead, and the publisher recommends Heartless to its fans.
- Alice's Adventures in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll — The source world. Meyer reread it and its sequel repeatedly and built her plot from its clues.
- The Lunar Chronicles (Cinder) by Marissa Meyer — Meyer's earlier fairy-tale series, and the yardstick critics use when calling Heartless lower in stakes and gentler.
Track this book
Add to your library to track progress and write reviews
